ENDNOTES, August 2020

Klimt, Hygeia

ENDNOTES, August 2020

In this edition: Brahms celebrated in Vienna – patriotic music denigrated in Britain, by Stuart Millson

The city of Vienna is home to two of the world’s greatest orchestras: the Vienna Philharmonic, once conducted by Karajan, and famous to a wide international audience via the annual New Year’s Day broadcast of Strauss waltzes and polkas; and the Vienna Symphony Orchestra – the ensemble that gave such world premieres as Bruckner’s Ninth Symphony and Schoenberg’s Gurrelieder. In proud homage to the music of Johannes Brahms (1833-97), the Wiener Symphoniker has set down on CD for the Sony label a new cycle of the great German composer’s four symphonies. Recorded live in 2019 at Vienna’s Musikverein – in the Golden Hall, no less – the orchestra, under the masterful baton of the distinguished Swiss conductor, Philippe Jordan, has produced what must rank as one of the best Brahms symphony sequences of recent years.

The recording has achieved that fine balance between a rich, overall sound – that late-romantic glow from a large orchestra – but with a spotlight on the delicate playing of the section principals, such as the yearning woodwind in the Andante and Allegretto movements in the titanic, yet tender, First Symphony, op. 68. Jordan directs the progress of the symphonic argument with restraint, allowing the music to find its own breath and pace – saving a great surge of noble energy for the final furlong of the great work, yet even then avoiding the temptation to wallow in too much expansive grandeur. This is a “Brahms 1” with clarity, definition, but never too heavy and overburdened with storm and stress. Continue reading

Posted in Cultural Matters, Current Affairs and Comment, ENDNOTES:Music, QR Home | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Half-Way Through the Plains

A. E. Housman

Half-Way Through the Plains

A Study of More Poems XXXV, by Darrell Sutton

Half-way, for one commandment broken,
The woman made her endless halt,
And she to-day, a glistering token,
Stands in the wilderness of salt.
Behind, the vats of judgment brewing
Thundered, and thick the brimstone snowed;
He to the hill of his undoing
Pursued his road.

Over the last seven decades several learned commentators have remarked upon the religious poems created by Housman, particularly those based on Biblical texts. An assemblage of those poems, and comments about them made by able literary critics, would comprise three thousand pages or more. Housman was a professed unbeliever in any deity. Many scholars have considered the reasons for an atheist’s fascination with holy scripture. Among them was Carol Efrati who published ‘Housman’s Use of Biblical Narrative‘, in A. Holden, J. Birch, A.E. Housman: A Reassessment (1999). There is much to admire in the essay, and her brief exposition of More Poems XXXV is relevant to ongoing discussions of the poem. But her handling of the text is eisegetic, and she does not go into the details of the structure of his verse.

Another examination is in order, I believe. Housman’s poem presents a picture of Lot, his wife, and the remembrance of them. The tale to which the poem alludes seems a strange basis upon which to originate a poem. Housman, however, thought otherwise, drawing together a compilation of ideas. The Gospel of Luke, 17:32, contains three short words, ‘Remember Lot’s Wife’. To this command of Christ, Housman was obedient – but not in the way originally intended by the first century AD Jewish rabbi. Wide-ranging thoughts led Housman to meditate on [literary] matters in the past, present, and future. The poems he composed encompass all three timespans. In poetry, he read widely. His interests took him into ancient Mesopotamia, Egypt, the texts of Greece and Rome, through medieval intervals, onward to the Romantic Poets and Victorian writers and their habitations. Several of Housman’s poems throw open wide the windows of history. Through carefully crafted lines of verse the characters drawn by him are fixed in readers’ memories. Many of his sentences are unforgettable. Who does not love the ‘blue remembered hills’ in ‘the land of lost content’? Besides, the recollected fields of yore were fertile grounds in which to plant the seeds of his fecund ideas. Some seedlings appeared in A Shropshire Lad and in Last Poems, then again in More Poems. Continue reading

Posted in Cultural Matters, Poetry, QR Home | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Bring in the Feds!

George Floyd/police brutality protests, Portland, Oregon

Bring in the Feds!

For Ilana Mercer, protection of natural rights trumps states’ rights

America circa 2020 continues to erupt in riots, spurred by the death-by-cop of George Floyd. The violence is qualitatively different to that which roiled the U.S. during the race riots of 1964. Whether you thought those riots right or wrong, back in 1964, state police officers were a forceful presence for law-and-order. They did damage to rioters as deliberately as they defended people and their property.

End-stage America” riots, referred to by the malfunctioning media as “peaceful protests,” have engulfed “over 2,000 cities and towns in all 50 states.” Even Wikipedia has conceded that “most large cities [have seen and are seeing] large scale rioting, looting, and burning of businesses and police cars.” You know how bad things are when such habitual liars for the Left admit to “large-scale” destruction by the Left. This “mostly peaceful” mob even murdered a man, in Minneapolis, and burned down a pawnshop, all in memory of George Floyd.

Neutered, coopted, infiltrated and compromised—the police force in 2020 is missing in action. In the rare event that they act in accordance with their constitutional obligation to protect innocent people and their property, the police are hobbled—prevented from deploying riot-control tactics and, thus, invariably “hurt and hospitalized.” “End-stage America” and its kneeling, pleading police force is the result of  institutional rot, brought about because of the Left’s lengthy control of the intellectual means of production (neocons and ConInkers are collaborators). In 1964, the law would not countenance the disruption of public order and tranquility. The law in 2020 has helped invert ordered liberty, so that, in America today, the law protects the outlaw against the law-abiding. Witness the case of Mark and Patricia McCloskey: riffraff invaded their grounds and encroached on their residence. The legacy media faulted the St. Louis couple, framing the two’s self-defense stance and deterrence as dangerous aggression. The law followed through with weapons confiscation and criminal charges. Continue reading

Posted in Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Against the Wind

Professor Richard Lynn

Against the Wind

Memoirs of a Dissident Psychologist, Richard Lynn, Ulster Institute for Social Research, 2020, reviewed by Ed Dutton 

At 90 years of age, Richard Lynn is the doyen of differential psychology. His findings on national and race differences in average IQ have made him the bogeyman of anti-science, left-wing ‘scientists’. But, as Memoirs of a Dissident Psychologist makes clear, Lynn’s contribution to the study of psychological differences goes far beyond the dogma-questioning research that persuaded the University of Ulster to spitefully strip him of his Emeritus Professorship. Truth to tell, Lynn discovered the ‘Flynn Effect’ – the secular rise in IQ scores of around 2.5 points per decade that took place in Western countries across the twentieth century. Often derided as a  ‘racist’ by anti-science opponents, he also demonstrated that Northeast Asians have higher average IQ than Europeans, overturning the previous ethnocentric assumption that they were the world’s most intelligent race.

One fascinating aspect of this book is the insight it provides into how scientists come up with their theories. There are relatively few autobiographies penned by scientists – at least compared to politicians and other limelight-seeking celebrities – so it is rare to see this process described. For example, Lynn was inspired to look into the issue of reading ability by noticing that his two year-old daughter appeared to be capable of learning individual letters. His finding that the Irish had particularly low levels of anxiety – when he also disproved that the stereotype that the Irish are heavy drinkers – came out of his period working for a research institute in Dublin, during which time he dined with the then Taoiseach Jack Lynch. Reading about how Napoleon’s soldiers survived eating frozen horses in Russia engendered Lynn’s Cold Winter’s Theory, his thesis that high intelligence was selected for among Europeans due to the complexity of the problems they had to solve, especially during the last Ice Age. Continue reading

Posted in Book Reviews, Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Woke – Curse of the Thinking Classes

Morgan Russell, Cosmic Synchrony

Woke – Curse of the Thinking Classes

Ilana Mercer on the enemy within

They’re unwilling to defend true dissidents, but Beltway lite libertarians and Con Inkers are forever genuflecting to privileged legacy journalists, who can afford to voluntarily leave their rich gigs in “protest” at cancel culture. The Right hasn’t shut up about the New Yorker’s Andrew Sullivan, who is far less banal than the New York Times’ Bari Weiss. Both belong to the “nothing new, more of the same” neoconservative tradition. Her resignation antics are a storm in a C-cup; his “defiant” departure is the fussy equivalent (just for gay men).

For a more meaningful scandal, to the Right at least, consider the farce of a Conservative news and opinion organization, founded by a dragon slayer of a broadcaster, which has published lacerating pieces condemning America’s foremost hate group, yet has proceeded to purge writers, in compliance with the demands of said shakedown hate group. American conservatism capitulating to America-haters? Negotiating with terrorists? Hypocrisy? Yes, yes, and yes. Supine is the natural position of the Establishment Republican, Con Inker, neoconservative, whatever his latest opportunistic, political permutation may be.

The news site is the Daily Caller. The hate group is the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC). The ransom demands issue from the illiterati of the SPLC, who regularly publish lists of—and hit pieces against—untouchable dissidents. They then proceed against us with all the vigor of a “a money grabbing slander machine,” to quote John Stossel, a veteran investigative journalist who has exposed this corrupt syndicate that lives off destroying people. For his part, economist Thomas DiLorenzo has skillfully pried apart the revenue-rich, “racial racketeering” of the Southern Poverty Law Center, showing it to be nothing more than a “hate group hedge fund.” Continue reading

Posted in Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Fake History, from the EU

William Bell Scott, Iron and Coal

Fake History, from the EU

William Hartley has iron in the soul

In 1999, recognising there was no single event which shaped the European landscape greater than the Industrial Revolution, Britain, Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands applied for EU funding to draw up a master plan. What flowed from this became known as the ‘Duisberg Declaration’. The aim was to create interest in the common European heritage of industrialisation. This became known as the European Route of Industrial Heritage. In terms of leisure and tourism it wasn’t a bad idea. After all, shouldn’t citizens of Europe learn about what shaped the modern world? This being an EU funded project, however, a problem arose through an overarching requirement to achieve commonality. Rather reluctantly, the ERIH only hints at where the industrial revolution originated before crossing to the continent. Evidently no nation was to be given a leading role.

There were various social, environmental and geological reasons why the industrial revolution began in Britain. The early start thesis has been well covered by economic historians and as we know that for Britain it meant both benefits and burdens. The ERIH moves quickly on from that awkward point of origin question, giving the impression that the industrial revolution was breaking out everywhere. Certainly, what followed in Europe was important. Yet much of what is to be found on the Route is nineteenth or even twentieth century in origin. The fact is that the building blocks of the Industrial Revolution originated in eighteenth century Britain. Continue reading

Posted in Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

When “Col. Mike” met the “Mercerator”

The Seattle East Police Precinct in the now defunct Autonomous Zone

When “Col. Mike” met the “Mercerator” 

Ilana Mercer, back on the air

On July 2, 2020, with my favorite radio broadcaster, “Col. Mike”, of the John Fredericks Show, syndicated out of Virginia, for a wide-ranging discussion of the issues of the day—from the Soweto-style shantytowns that had sprung-up in Seattle, to China and the Covid quagmire, to America’s immigration-visa labyrinth, and much more.

In his interview style, the Colonel, so dubbed in deference to his military rank, will remind older listeners of the legendary George Putnam (by whom I was honored to be interviewed years back). Thus, when this columnist ventured to say that the Seattle police had no business deserting their headquarters and posts; that their first duty was to uphold the rights of the citizens of Seattle, not to obey the politized commands of Police Chief Carmen Best and Mayor Jenny Durkan—Col. Mike, who knows a thing or two about a chain-of-command, roared: “They should all be fired.” Continue reading

Posted in Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Fear of Frying

Statue of Martin Luther, Frauenkirche, Dresden

Fear of Frying

Dresden, the Fire and the Darkness, Sinclair McKay, Viking (imprint of Penguin Books), 2020, reviewed by Leslie Jones

“Man is at bottom a savage, horrible beast”, Arthur Schopenhauer

Historian James Holland, a ubiquitous presence on television programmes about World War 2 these days, featured in ‘Lost Home Movies of Nazi Germany’. In the undated footage in question, a group of Jews are being deported from Dresden. Holland confides that he had always considered the city “an innocent place”, bombed needlessly in February 1945. But having watched this amateur film, he reminds us that it was also a rail hub with over 140 factories producing war material. For example, from 1942 the Zeiss Ikon camera plant produced precision instruments and optical technology for the military. It employed slave labour, including Jewish women. In this “hotbed of Nazism”, Holland maintains, the Jews were dealt with as brutally as anywhere in Germany. He acknowledges, however, that the Dresden firestorm was “horrendous”, something of an understatement.

In ‘Greatest Events of World War 2 – Dresden Firestorm’, Holland returned to this contentious subject. He referred to the German air raids on England, notably those on London and Coventry but conceded that in all of these attacks, ‘only’ 40,000 people were killed. Dresden suffered more losses between the 13th and 15th of February. Holland blames the Nazi authorities in Dresden, notably the Gauleiter of Saxony, Martin Mutschmann (‘King Mu’), for failing to build air raid shelters for the civilian population (but not for himself). Continue reading

Posted in Book Reviews, Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Failure of Canadian Conservatism

Justin Trudeau at the Vancouver Pride Parade, 2018

The Failure of Canadian Conservatism

Mark Wegierski, writing on the 153rd anniversary of Canadian Confederation

This essay is partially based on Mark Wegierski’s paper, ‘An Ineluctable Direction of Progressive Development?: The Ongoing Failure of the Right in Canada’ (read by Dr. Tomasz Soroka). 8th Congress of Polish Canadianists (Polish Association for Canadian Studies) ‘Canadian (Re)Visions: Futures, Changes, Revolutions’ (Lodz, Poland: University of Lodz, Faculty of Philology) PACS. September 25-27, 2019

Canada has indeed developed far away from its origins. July 1, 2020 is the 153rd anniversary of Canadian Confederation. That was the date on which the British North America Act (Canada’s original constitution) was passed in 1867 by the British Parliament. Four provinces (Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia) formed Confederation. It was also a union of two, long pre-existent nations, English Canada, and French Canada (the latter mostly centered in the province of Quebec). The Aboriginal peoples were included insofar as they were traditionally considered to be under the special protection of the Crown. The Canadian Constitution of 1867 was anti-revolutionary. What was called the Dominion of Canada was characterized by “peace, order, and good government” in contrast to the American credo of “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness”.

Until 1896, the Conservatives under John A. Macdonald dominated the Canadian polity. Macdonald was a real nation-builder, extending the railways across the continent, thus bringing British Columbia into Confederation in 1871. He also suppressed the two Riel Rebellions which stood in the way of a coast-to-coast Canada. However, the execution of Louis Riel for treason was a baneful act. Indeed, in the 1896 federal election, French Quebec turned away from the Conservatives, voting en masse for the Liberal Party of Wilfrid Laurier.

Throughout most of the Twentieth Century, Quebec would overwhelmingly support the Liberal Party in federal elections, thus virtually guaranteeing a Liberal majority in the federal Parliament. However, until the 1963 federal election, this did not have socially radical implications for Canada, as the country was dominated by a “traditionalist-centrist” social consensus. Indeed, even the social democratic third party, the Co-operative Commonwealth Federation (CCF), was mostly socially conservative. However, in 1961, the party changed its name to New Democratic Party (NDP), which suggested a more “futurist” orientation. Continue reading

Posted in Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

A Writer’s Writer in an Age of Mediocrity

H L Mencken, 1928

A Writer’s Writer in an Age of Mediocrity

Ilana Mercer on H.L. Mencken

H.L. Mencken, a contrarian polemicist and consummate critic, who wrote prolifically from 1899 until 1948, may no longer seem relevant, but the fault would not be his. Mencken was a well-read bon vivant with a taste for Teutonic philosophy and a fidelity to immutable truth. He was also a brilliant satirist and a writer whose facility with the English idiom and grasp of intellectual history are unsurpassed.

How can a phenom like Mencken appeal in our age, The Age of the Idiot? He can’t: he should, but he can’t. Henry Louis Mencken cannot appeal to the bumper crops of humorless, dour “dunderheads” America is now siring. He cannot resonate with those who are afraid to question received opinion, who cannot conjugate a verb correctly, use tenses, prepositions and adjectives grammatically and creatively, or appreciate a clever turn-of-phrase.

How can Mencken, author of The American Language (1919), be relevant in an America in which the rules of syntax are passé, pronouns are politicized and neutered, torrential prolixity is in, concision and precision are out, and “editors” excise nothing, preferring to let mangled phrases and lumpen jargon spill onto the page like gravy over a tablecloth. Continue reading

Posted in Current Affairs and Comment, QR Home | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment