On An Anonymous Reviewer – Catharine Savage Brosman

On an Anonymous Reviewer


A man? A woman? Quite close-lipped,

at least, invited to assess

a scholar’s lengthy manuscript.

It was shot down, without finesse.


“The work, I see, does not succeed

except most literally; such

will not suffice now.  As I read

its flaws grow evident.  Too much


historical concern – the worms

of time; too little theory, too;

clear prejudice revealed by terms.”

(The context does not count; what’s true


depends on dogma, and we must

rewrite the past as it should be.)

“Insensitive in tone, unjust;

two small mistakes in chapter three.”


In retrospect, it was naive

to think postmoderns might be fair;

they obviously can’t conceive

how they are blindly doctrinaire.




The wheels of fortune surely turn;

your book may be the next to burn.


CATHARINE SAVAGE BROSMAN is the poetry editor of Chronicles.

An interview with her may be read here




This entry was posted in QR Home and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *